Welcome to Andy’s Restaurant & Pizza
At Andy’s Restaurant & Pizza, nestled in Sea Girt, NJ, we celebrate a passion for authentic Italian cuisine with a focus on pizza. Our inviting atmosphere is perfect for both casual dining and quick bites, boasting outdoor seating and a family-friendly vibe. Guests rave about our signature dishes, like the Pizza Zingara, loaded with artichoke hearts and olives, and our Sicilian pizza, which ensures satisfaction with every bite. With a commitment to quality, our seasoned staff creates a welcoming environment, making Andy’s a beloved fixture for locals and visitors alike. Indulge in the heart of Italian tradition, right here.
Andy’s Restaurant & Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
I used to consistently buy the Pizza Zingara (artichoke hearts and black olives) and always enjoyed it. Today, my dining companion wanted to try Sicilian, so we went for it. No regrets. Enjoyed it quite a bit. Wanted to stop at one slice, but had to go for two. Perfect amount of mozzarella, good sauce, and cooked just right -- not under or over. Service was good, place and ladies room were very clean, and it is a pizzaria/restaurant, so you can have a sit-down dinner in the back in addition to having some tables to have a quick bite in the pizza area. Stop by if you are in the area and are hungry. Solid.
Actually the food is really good here. The owner is a little grumpy but I think it's because he's working so much. He seems to really want to get your order right. I really like Andy's.
Before I write my review, lemme just start by saying the pizza is excellent, service is good, and food always comes out quick. BUT... I bought the lemonade and open it and to my surprise it starts fizzing like soda. I sip it and it tastes like lemony Sprite but the weirdest part is it smells yeasty like it got fermented. I didn't really care but I'm just writing this to warn the owners/workers of the pizzeria because this could definitely cause problems with future customers and even health inspections. Note: Yes I checked the ingredients to make sure it wasn't just a fizzy beverage. There was no carbonated water or sodium bicarbonate that could react with the acidity of the lemons. So not really sure what else it could be.
I love Andy's. In my opinion, they make the best vegetable pizza I ever had. I appreciate that the guys are always so nice and friendly when I go there. never got let down by them....always A+
Great pizza. Always enjoy a trip to the beach and grab a pie at Andy's. Had the cheese calzones before and would recommend them as well. Traditional pie like NYC.
I love Andy's Pizzeria. I've been coming here since it opened in 1973. It was the first "real pizza" in Monmouth County. Only one complaint; I wish it was open on Sunday. But I do understand, being raise Roman Catholic . Otherwise, Try it!
Andy's pizza is definitely one of my favorites in the Jersey shore area the pasta's and the cheesesteaks are so yummy you won't regret coming here not only is the food amazing but the staff is super friendly and very kind. They offer a variety of delicious dessert and even ice cream. Andy's also has two sections the dinner section and then a small section if you are in a hurry. They keep their bathrooms very clean and also the restaurant looks very neat.
Location
-
Sea Girt Ave & State Sea Girt, NJ 08750 United States Hotline: (732) 820-4010
Welcome to Andy’s Restaurant & Pizza, nestled in the heart of Sea Girt, NJ. Known for its cozy yet vibrant atmosphere, Andy’s is a culinary gem that combines traditional Italian flavors with a casual dining experience. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this pizzeria is a must-visit for anyone craving authentic pizza and more.
Andy’s Restaurant & Pizza stands out not only for its delicious offerings but also for the variety of options available. With a menu that features many vegetarian choices and crowd-pleasers like the famed Pizza Zingara—topped with artichoke hearts and black olives—there’s something to satisfy every palate. Moreover, patrons rave about the Sicilian pizza, which boasts the perfect balance of mozzarella and sauce, cooked to perfection. As one enthusiastic diner, Catherine B., remarked, “Had to go for two slices; it was that good!”
The ambiance is inviting, with options for casual dining as well as quick bites. Andy’s combines a laid-back vibe with the comfort of outdoor seating and a family-friendly atmosphere, making it ideal for groups and children alike. The restaurant is also equipped with televisions for watching your favorite games while enjoying a refreshing drink or a slice of pie. And yes, they accept credit cards for convenience!
- Utilities: Delivery, Takeout, Reservations
- Dining Options: Outdoor Seating, Casual Dress
- Features: Good for Groups, Good for Kids, TV, Alcohol
While the food garners high praise, Andy's is also known for its attentive service. Although some may humorously comment on the owner’s grumpy demeanor, it’s evident that his commitment to customer satisfaction remains unwavering. As David P. noted, “The food is really good here,” highlighting that the dedication to quality shines through.
Whether you're there for the delicious pies or the friendly service, it’s clear that Andy’s Restaurant & Pizza delivers a solid experience. Enjoy the comfort of a sit-down dinner or grab a quick slice to-go after a day at the beach. With so many loyal patrons, it’s no wonder why this establishment has become a favorite in the community. So, if you're in the area and hunger strikes, make your way to Andy’s—you won't regret it!
